Showing posts with label Miami Dolphins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miami Dolphins. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

No Excuses for Tannehill




The Miami Dolphins are trying to climb out of mediocrity. Four straight seasons below .500 has left the fan base dull. The Dolphins won the offseason, changed their logo, and generated a little bit of buzz for this year. That won't last unless they win.

This offseason looks to be about acquiring play makers. General manager Jeff Ireland is trying to put the right pieces around second year quarterback Ryan Tannehill. Ireland went out and brought in Mike Wallace, a dynamic deep threat that Tannehill was missing last year. The team also signed Dustin Keller, an athletic tight end and security blanket for Tannehill.

Fans were clamoring for these moves. These signings appeased the fan base, but also raised the expectations and eliminated the excuses for Tannehill. Last season, Tannehill fluctuated from brilliant to pedestrian. His supporters consistently pointed to the Dolphins' lack of a true number one receiver. They marveled at his ability to move the offense without a deep threat to stretch the field, or a reliable tight end to create space over the middle.

Now those excuses are gone. Miami will be looking for Tannehill to lead this team to the playoffs. While no one would argue that the Dolphins are loaded on offense, they clearly have enough to win a wild card spot. These moves will force people to judge Tannehill based on production instead of potential. Instead of wondering what he could do with talent around him, fans will have the answers laid out in front of them. Tannehill will be held accountable to improve on his average 76.1 quarterback rating and his mediocre 6.81 yards per pass attempt, and he won't be bailed out by the constant hope of potential.

Miami is expecting the playoffs. The city is expecting Tannehill to deliver. Fans are expecting him to improve. They hope these signings will push them into the playoffs. If nothing else, these moves will now allow the city and organization to take an accurate assessment of their quarterback.

Friday, April 5, 2013

Dolphins Mortgaging Future to Win Now



There is a lot of debate as to what makes an NFL team great. Some say you need an elite quarterback. Others say you need a great coach. The old school thinks that physical defense and hard running can still get your team a ring.

If you think back to all the great dynasties of the NFL, they succeeded in a myriad of different ways. Don Shula's Dolphins pummeled opponents with big running backs and a stiff defense. Bill Walsh's 49ers spread the field and threw over the competition. Jimmy Johnson's Cowboys won with balance.

There's not a secret schematic formula to win a Superbowl. There is only one thing that every NFL dynasty has in common, stability. Every great organization was either built around one coach, or one group of players. These teams slowly added the right pieces around their talent over several years, following a singular blueprint, and producing consistent success.

Right now, the Miami Dolphins have a pile of blueprints all drawn on top of each other. The reason why the Dolphins haven't been successful in over a decade is because they keep changing the plan every few years.

When Dan Marino retired, the Dolphins and Dave Wannstedt tried to build a team around Ricky Williams and a stellar defense. It almost worked, getting them to the playoffs every year, but never advancing very far.

When the team introduced Nick Saban, he brought in a bunch of veterans at the end of their primes, for big money. By the time he bolted for Alabama, the team was full of washed up and over priced albatrosses. The once vaunted Miami defense was hardly recognizable.

Cam Cameron was going to “fail forward fast” with his mix of spread and vertical passing concepts. Unfortunately, all Cameron did was fail fast and was gone within a year. The only relic from his era that's still around is Paul Soliai.

Bill Parcells and his unholy triumvirate of Jeff Ireland and Tony Sparano laid another blueprint on the stack and tore up the previous foundation. Parcells traded away long time linebacker Jason Taylor, and drafted tackle Jake Long. Parcells wanted to smash the ball down the middle, and win with defense.

After a few years of middling success, only Ireland is left. The most recent coach to be brought to the slaughter is Joe Philbin. Philbin runs a west coast offense! He's trying to sling the ball around with players that Parcells brought in to run the ball between the tackles!

This lack of a singular vision for the team, leads Miami to turn over its roster every few years. Any time a team lays a new foundation, they take a hit in talent. The best players for the old system leave town, and the new regime needs a few drafts to bring in talent to fit the new scheme.

That's why consistency is so important. If a team has an unchanging set of attributes that they value at each position, they can develop stars in their system and build depth through multiple drafts and free agency periods. If a team changes their values every offseason, they end up with a bunch of mismatched puzzle pieces that they try to plug into a new system. In other words, a mess. That's the Miami Dolphins.

The teams that do it the best, the Pittsburgh Steelers and the New England Patriots understand this concept. The Steelers have only had three coaches since 1969! Three! The Dolphins have gone through three coaches in three years before. The New England Patriots have been hand crafted by Bill Belichick. Every piece has been thoroughly inspected to see if it fits, before he inserts it into the starting line up.

I do not think Jeff Ireland is a great general manager, or even a good one. However, the Dolphins have stumbled into some consistency with him. His recent actions lead me to realize that even he knows this is his last chance to get things right. That's why he went out and won the off season. Ireland threw money at Mike Wallace and severely overpaid for some low impact linebackers and an above average tight end.

Have you looked at the money on those deals? Ireland back loaded them. The big money doesn't kick in until next year. Mike Wallace signed a $60 million deal. His salary this year is $1 million. Next year, it's $15 million. Ireland set up all the contracts this way, so he could bring in a bunch of talent under the cap this year and worry about the problems next year. This is irrational. It will leave the Dolphins strapped for cash for the next few off seasons.

This is a symptom of the lack of consistency in the Miami Dolphins organization. The brass has to constantly mortgage the future in a desperate attempt to keep his job. This leaves a mess for the next guy to clean up, and by the time he has finally cleaned it up, he gets fired.

I'm not arguing that Jeff Ireland is the man that we need to build around, but the Dolphins need to identify a guy they believe in and hand him the keys to the organization. They need to find someone they trust and let him build a team, through multiple drafts, and multiple off seasons. Miami needs one vision and one system that they can follow and build a consistent winner. Overhauling the team every few years is not the way to do it. If the Dolphins want to win a Superbowl, they need to create some stability.


Sunday, January 20, 2013

Is Tannehill the Answer?




The NFL season is over. The Dolphins stunningly missed the playoffs, again. Indifference runs rampant over the city of Miami. But one question needs to be answered, is Ryan Tannehill the next Marino or the next Cleo Lemon? That's the big question, right? That's what this whole season has really been about. This season wasn't about making the playoffs. It wasn't really about rebuilding either. It was a 16 week audition to see if Ryan Tannehill is a franchise quarterback.

The Dolphins looked competitive all year, but not spectacular, and from the basic stats, the same could be said for Tannehill. Here's his line:

YearTeamGAttCompPctAtt/GYdsAvgYds/GTDTD%IntInt%Lng20+40+SckSckYRate
2012Miami Dolphins1648428258.330.23,2946.8205.9122.5132.780T4033523476.1


Pretty good. I mean, we are currently in an era where the top quarterbacks are throwing for 5,000 yards, everybody is throwing for 4,000 yards and our quarterback barely threw for 3,000 yards. But hey, at least he didn't do this. The advanced stats are not as friendly. Here is where he stacks up according to Football Outsiders' advanced stats:

DYAR: 25th
DVOA: 25th
QBR: 19th

Not so great. Bottom third of the league. Ah, the Dolphins, nothing if not consistently underwhelming. Yes, he's only a rookie but how far does that excuse go? We've been through this with Henne. He showed flashes and then had some duds. Henne observers broke into two camps, one wanted to oust him in his second season, and the other preached patience. I was even leaning on the patience side, saying that he needed more time, that stability at quarterback would lead to winning, and I didn't want to rebuild again. While all of that is true, none of those statements are endorsements of his talent. It was obvious he wasn't going to be the guy, and I never realized it. I can't say many different things about Tannehill. Just for fun, here are the stats for Henne's first year:

YearTeamGAttCompPctAtt/GYdsAvgYds/GTDTD%IntInt%Lng20+40+SckSckYRate
2009Miami Dolphins                         1445127460.832.22,8786.4205.6122.7143.1672342617675.2

Yikes...

That is pretty similar. However, Henne had Brandon Marshall at receiver, and Tannehill is throwing to this guy. Hartline and Bess haven't exactly been creating a lot of separation on the field. I mean even Manti Te'o's fake girlfriend was better at keeping her distance from defensive players. Sorry.

But the lack of a number one receiver shouldn't be overlooked. Football is an inexact science, and we can't really tell when a receiver makes a quarterback look good or when a quarterback makes a receiver look good. Except for the case of Brandon Stokley and Peyton Manning. If it wasn't for Peyton Manning, Brandon Stokley would clearly be a sandwich artist at some Subway in Virginia by now.

The big number that I look at in judging quarterbacks is completion percentage. I value accuracy above every other trait in a quarterback. I always like rolling the dice on an accurate passer. You can keep the big-armed QB and hope he turns into the next Brett Favre or John Elway but you will probably end up with another Jamarcus. I will draft the accurate quarterback and hope he turns into Aaron Rodgers, but will settle for Rich Gannon.

That being said, Tannehill's completion percentage isn't bad, but it isn't great either. Again, he is in the lower third of the league in that category. Other QB's with similar completion percentages to him: Jay Cutler, Blaine Gabbert, Cam Newton, and Matt Cassel. That's not what I would call stellar company, the only elite quarterback in that group may be Cam, who's completion percentage is skewed by how many deep passes he throws.

Unlike LeBron's hairline, completion percentage doesn't change much during a player's career. Completion percentage may fluctuate by a couple of points when a player enters his prime or upgrades receivers, but rarely does someone jump into that elite level of completing 63-68 per cent of their passes from 58 per cent.

The only modern example I found of a player having a big jump in completion percentage actually had similar stats to Tannehill in his rookie year.

YearTeamGAttCompPctAtt/GYdsAvgYds/GTDTD%IntInt%Lng20+40+SckSckYRate
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX            1657532656.735.93,7396.5233.7264.5284.978T4282210971.2

Pretty close right? Player B had more yards but also had more attempts. He threw for more TD's and picks, but had a similar ratio to our boy Tanny. But like I said, Player B had a big jump in completion percentage the rest of his career and currently has a career completion percentage of 65 per cent.

So who is Player B?

Only Peyton Manning!

Now that's what's up! Dolphins missed on Peyton but drafted the future Peyton? Yeah! Throw away the Fireland posters! Give him an extension!

Not quite.

Peyton is the exception, and most definitely, not the rule. Most quarterbacks don't improve their percentages during their career by that much from their baseline percentage displayed in their rookie year.

It doesn't mean that Tannehill can't be the next Peyton, but it means that he probably won't.

As I watched Tannehill all year, I saw a few flashes of a future All-Pro. I also saw a lot of third down ineptitude. And all those excuses ran through my head to defend him. What discouraged me, was looking at the other rookie quarterbacks and seeing how few questions surrounded them.

Here in Miami, we're all asking if Tannehill is the answer. Desperately hoping he is.

In DC, nobody is asking if RGIII is the answer.

Same thing with Luck and Russell Wilson. Indy and Seattle are confident they have found their franchise quarterbacks. Those fan bases are planning trips to the playoffs for the next ten years.

Its like getting married, if you have to convince yourself that she's the one. She's probably not the one. Likewise if you have to convince yourself that you have a franchise quarterback, you probably don't.

Let me just say that I hope I am wrong. I hope all of you flood my Twitter with this link when Tannehill is winning the Superbowl in a few years. I genuinely like the guy. And I like that we took a chance and drafted a quarterback in the first round. However, I think it was a two quarterback draft and we got the third. (I'm not going to count Russell Wilson against them.)

There is still a chance for Tannehill to develop into a special player. Again, the arguments for him are that he is only a rookie, playing without a number one receiver, or any legitimate play makers on offense. We have to fill those holes, and build around this kid. Give it some time and we will know in the next two seasons if Tannehill is the answer. If he makes the leap and can improve his play in the next two years, he may be the solution. If not, fire up the QB carousel. It will be time for the Dolphins to start over and pick another passer at the top of the 2015 draft.

Bummer.

Go Dolphins.  

Saturday, May 12, 2012

Dolphins Draft Recap




Miami has the Dolphins! The greatest football team! We take the ball from goal to goal! And kick field goals like a dream!

My poor, poor Dolphins. In search of hope. With nothing but a famous running back and Canadian pass rusher to hold onto.

The draft was just what they needed. Something to bring in hope, sell tickets, and raise expectations.

I’ll be honest with you, they reeled me in. This is the Dolphins draft I’ve wanted for 10 years. They got me a quarterback. They spent a high pick on a pass rusher. They drafted a pass catching tight end!

I laughed as I monitored Facebook and Twitter during the draft. Most of my fellow Dolfans were pushing for Ireland to get fired, yet were struggling to hide their excitement with this draft. There were a lot of backhanded compliments and optimistic posts ending with potshots at Ireland to save face.

So is the plight of the Dolphin fan.

Let’s just be honest. This draft is exciting. For the most part we focused on high impact positions. That’s all I care about. Yes, the draft is an unknown venture that is impossible to quantify for several years. But that won’t stop me from trying!

Boom! Draft recap!

1st pick- Ryan Tannehill

Ireland must really like this guy. Or he’s been saying he likes this guy to save face about whiffing on Peyton, RG3, and Luck. Either way, I’m excited. Word was leaked that the Dolphins’ brass thought Tannehill was the best QB prospect they had seen in 10 years. I’m gonna have to call BS on that, but I like the effort. The PR spin is in full effect, but you know what, we will love that coded language if the Dolphins are winning Superbowls while holding everything close to the vest.

Anyways, on to Tannehill himself. As a prospect, I didn’t love him. He played receiver most of his college career. It took him until his senior year to beat out Jerrod Johnson. Ask any Texas A&M fan about that, who has watched Jerrod Johnson fire five yard flare routes into the dirt, and they will tell you that its not a good omen for Tanny. He wasn’t elite in the Big 12. He didn’t win any significant games against top teams. He wasn’t near the leaderboards for any major passing category. But overall I like the pick.

Why?

Oh, I’ll tell you why.

We had to pull the trigger eventually! Ever since Marino retired, all I’ve heard is that this isn’t the year to draft a QB. Next year is a much better crop. Then we get to next year and they say the same bleeping thing. I’m tired of it. Every year we wait on a QB. Sign a retread, or draft a project in a later round. Then they try to sell me on the value. Now anyone who has seen me buy half my wardrobe at Goodwill will tell you that I love value. However, it doesn’t work at QB. Look at all the QB’s in the playoffs last year. Brady is a once an era exception. Brees was the first pick in the second round, and everyone else was a first round pick.

Teams pick quarterbacks in the first round, because first round quarterbacks win. At least more than any other type of quarterback.

I definitely thought we reached for Tannehill. And he may not have been a first round pick if the Dolphins weren’t picking there. If I had to guess, I would lean towards him being a bust. But I don’t care. I’m glad we took a chance. We could have drafted a solid guard to fill out another offensive line spot for a decade. But having an All-Pro guard doesn’t win you big games. Just ask Blindside.

All the talking heads like to make football sound really complicated. And it is an intricate game. But most of the players at most of the positions are pretty equal. And the difference between having an All-Pro guard instead of a journeyman probably isn’t a single win. But the difference between having an All-Pro quarterback instead of a journeyman is probably 6-8 wins. Do you see what I’m saying? Is there a way we can hire an economist to run the Dolphins? He would agree with me. Or she! Sorry ladies.

Quarterback is a high impact position where difference makers don’t become available. You have to draft quarterbacks to get a good one. Rarely does a team let one go. The other positions like that are DE/OLB (whoever rushes the passer), TE (Gronk isn’t going anywhere), CB, WR (name me all the big WR signings that have worked in the past 5 years, go talk to a Seahawks fan), and maybe LT (I think Jake Long is a stud but you can normally find a good tackle late in his career who will still play at a high level). Bottom line, you have to draft and develop your own difference makers. That’s why the Steelers have won so many games in the history of their existence.

The most high impact of all the high impact positions is quarterback. A good QB can cover up a lot of other deficiencies. So if we hit on a good QB, most of our problems are solved. The bulk of the improvement will be done and we can fill in the pieces around him. It is so cliche to call a quarterback the cornerstone of a franchise. But its true. You need a good one to build around, or else you’re just dressing up a Motel 6.

I wasn’t high on Tanny as a prospect. But I like him as a person. After he was drafted, I stalked his and his wife’s Twitter page. They are likable people. This was the first draft where I felt like these guys were normal guys. Not market trained, over saturated, media icons. Tanny’s Twitter felt like a normal person’s Twitter. Not a successful athlete who makes a page and starts interacting with 50,000 fans. Tannehill and his wife sound like average college kids who were tweeting to 300 of their friends about going to dinner and cramming for finals.

I understand that has nothing to do with football. But I will definitely be rooting for Tanny to succeed.

2nd pick- Jonathan Martin

I don’t know anything about this guy. I don’t watch a lot of left coast football, and when I did, my eyes were glued to Andrew Luck and Oregon’s chrome helmets. But I didn’t see Andrew Luck get knocked around a lot, so I guess I gotta give props to this kid. We had a hole with Vernon Carey leaving. A 300 lb donut eating hole on the right side of the line that this kid can fill. Sadly, I don’t know if he will ever have as much swag as Carey.

3rd pick- Oliver Vernon

The Dolphins are picking Hurricanes again? After all the Pro Bowlers left? Oh well.

I liked the Vernon pick as well. Mostly based on my high impact preference of drafting. I like anytime my team picks a pass rusher. He is undersized but very quick. Just like every other UM linebacker since Ray Lewis. But if this guy can move off the edge and bring some pressure, it will be splendid. Boom or bust? I have no idea. But keep picking QB’s and pass rushers, Ireland!

4th pick- Michael Egnew

Ok, some things you don’t know about Craig.

1. I’ve listened to Call Me Maybe more than once in the past 24 hours.

2. I’ve been wearing track pants all week.

3. I’ve been a Michael Egnew fan for years!

I was so hyped about this pick. Egnew can ball. The kid is a freak athlete at tight end. We haven’t had a TE like this since skinny Randy McMichael, before he started drinking a lot and beating his wife.

As much as I hate to admit it, Belichick got ahead of the curve. Remember when I was pushing for us to hire Chud? It was because I loved two tight end sets, and now I think the NFL does, too. The future of the NFL are players like Jimmy Graham and Rob Gronkowski. Large tree trunk shaped monsters that can jump really high and catch touchdowns.

Egnew can be that guy. He is 6’5 252 lbs and ran a 4.6. This guy has the physical tools, and more than that he’s proven. Jimmy Graham was an unknown commodity when he entered the league. Michael Egnew was an ALL AMERICAN!

I almost feel bad for Egnew. My expectations are so high for him, that unless he is the second coming of Shannon Sharpe, I’m going to be disappointed.

But its hope!

Hope!

5th pick- Lamar Miller

I liked the Lamar Miller pick, too. I like how we were aggressive and traded up for a falling prospect. Biased homers down in South Florida had him being a fringe first round pick. While I don’t think he should have been that, he was still great value in the 5th round.

As a Gator fan, I spent many a Saturday rooting against Lamar Miller and watching him burst through holes in the line and chalk up first down after first down. The guy has talent, but is an injury concern.

He could be a non factor or he could be the next Frank Gore. That is the obvious comparison, and I can’t think of a better type of player to take a flyer on.

6th pick- Josh Kannu

Oregon’s primary pass rusher. Oregon didn’t have a great D, but I think that had a lot to do with the pace of their offense as well. So we should cut Kannu some slack. This guy has potential but I’m no expert on him. However, I remember he had a high rating in NCAA Football 12. So that’s a good sign.

7th pick- BJ Cunningham

He broke all the school records at Michigan St. He’s not big for his position (6’1) or extraordinarily fast (4.5), but he produced in college. And what’s left of the Trifecta loves production. Charles Rogers and anyone that Jeff Smoker threw to has turned me off of Michigan St. receivers. Prove me wrong, BJ! Prove me wrong!

8th pick- Kheeston Randall

Big nose tackle from Texas. He is a project and will get limited snaps behind Solai. Meh.

9th pick- Rishard Matthews

Never heard of him. Who cares?

I’ll use this space instead to link you to this hilarious article about Jimmy Clausen’s misadventure to Supercuts.

All in all, I am pumped about this draft. I don’t expect the Dolphins to rise above their purgatory of mediocrity this season, but if Tanny shines, we all shine together. And we finally rolled the dice on a QB. That’s all I can ask. If it doesn’t work out, take another one. Keep taking them until we find a good one. If you load your team up with talent at the high impact positions, and fill in the rest through free agency, that’s how you win consistently. It is through that type of building, that the Dolphins can reclaim our highest franchise win percentage from the Steelers. I’m gunnin’ for you Pittsburgh.

C-Note out.

Saturday, March 24, 2012

What are the Dolphins Doing?



I just don’t get it, guys.

Can someone fill me in on the plan?

Can someone let me know what the vision is?

Can someone convince me that Stephen Ross is not turning into a less successful Daniel Snyder?

What are we doing?

Let’s talk about quarterbacks for a minute. The Dolphins seem to be waiting for Joey Marino and just killing time with one year fill ins.

Sure, we missed on Peyton. I was bummed, but I wasn’t shocked. Why would he come to Miami? Our perfect season that happened 40 years ago certainly isn’t a draw. Neither is our unstable leadership. I doubt the “rally” of 14 fans protesting to fire Ireland will reassure future free agents who are thinking of coming here. Our hobbled left tackle and stabbed wide receiver (we will get to that) won’t reel him in either.

Peyton wanted to be with people he knew and liked. People who believed in him and would be there for the rest of his career. He wanted a team that would let him run his offense, and had money to bring in his guys. Miami didn’t have that. The Dolphins are a broken organization. We haven’t won a playoff game in 10 years, we haven’t been relevant since Marino, and we haven’t won a championship in 40 years. This is a franchise that is falling from prestige to laughingstock at an alarming rate. We’re becoming the Raiders. All we offered Manning was leverage for his agent.

Then we whiffed on Flynn. I was surprised about that, but actually like Ireland’s maneuvering. He managed to drive Flynn’s price way down, and if there is one man who should know what Flynn is worth, its Joe Philbin. Ireland refused to overpay for the QB and lost him to Seattle. It happens. However, I think this is more about Philbin’s hubris than Ireland being concerned with value. I might be wrong, but most new coaches who are coming off a lot of success, like Philbin is, tend to overestimate their own abilities. Philbin saw what he did with Favre, Rodgers, and a few games of Flynn and probably thinks he has the Midas touch with quarterbacks. He’s probably wrong, but the Miamian in me wants so dearly for him to be right.

Ross’ most anti-Snyderian move was not pursuing Tebow. A move I obviously disagree with. Yes, I am an evangelical Gator fan, and unashamed Tebow fan, but I think the Jets made a great move in trading for him. Say what you want about him as a quarterback, but he definitely has a useful skill set in the NFL. Tebow greatly improves a team’s running game, and scores touchdowns in the red zone. Dolphins’ fans’ biggest complaint these past three years has been Sparano’s infatuation for field goals in the red zone. Now, he’s finally listened and addressed that problem in his offense by getting 240 pounds of concrete and cyanide to hammer the ball through the goal line. Except now he’s coaching for the Jets.

Then we sign Garrard. We signed a Pro Bowl starter at QB! Superbowl or bust! 19-0!

I just don’t get it. Granted, he’s not AS bad as people are making him out to be, but he is not the answer, especially in the long term. I’ll give this to Garrard, he is an average quarterback, who completes over 60% of his passes. He also takes care of the ball. But c’mon. You’re going to leave the hunt for Peyton Manning holding up David Garrard as your trophy? You can’t help it if the league sees you as a joke.

Its like we tried to sign Jay Z, missed on Tyga, then didn’t go after Drake, and decided to bring Mase out of retirement like it was a big deal.

Can’t nobody hold us down.

Its a bad situation, but its understandable that the quarterback search didn’t go as we had planned it. And I don’t mind Matt Moore. For a six week stretch he was a top ten quarterback, and the Dolphins might have been the best team in football. Then Jake Long got hurt, and Moore floundered under pressure. You can make the playoffs with Matt Moore, but everything has to fall just right. Win the Superbowl with Matt Moore? That’s nearly impossible. But that’s not why I’m so disappointed. That’s not why I feel as hopeless today as I did after the 1-15 season. I just want to know: what exactly is the plan now?

We don’t seem committed to anything. There are really only two ways to go as a team, you can try to win it this year, or you rebuild. A team that is trying to win this year goes after veteran talent to add to their core, thinking they are only a few players away from the championship. The Dolphins are doing this by pursuing Peyton Manning, signing Richard Marshall, going after Mark Anderson, resigning Paul Soliai, and picking up David Garrard.

Rebuilding teams, dump pricey veterans to create cap room and acquire picks to build around their young core for a future title run. The Dolphins are also doing this by trading Brandon Marshall away and cutting Yeremiah Bell.

I don’t have problems with the Dolphins pursuing either plan. We have a good defense and may be a few pieces and a lot of luck from a wild card spot. However, the Dolphins have a lot of holes and do not have many truly elite players. I would understand if we cut our losses and built around the few young, rising stars we have.

Instead, the Dolphins decided to do both. You can’t do both! Its one or the other. You can’t go into rebuilding mode on offense while strengthening your veteran defense. The stripped down offense will keep you from the playoffs and the stout defense will keep you from a high draft pick. You know where that puts you? 8-8. NFL purgatory. Where we have been for 10 years.

The problem goes back to the Dolphins having too many blueprints and no consistency. Ireland still has some of Cam Cameron’s guys on the roster, Parcells’ guys are still under contract, and he is just putting his own guys into place. But this season we added another blueprint. Another leader, with another vision for the team in Joe Philbin. Philbin and Mike Sherman want new guys on offense to fit their scheme, they want to get rid of Sparano’s pieces and bring in their own. Except, Ireland is still on thin ice. Ross’ unwavering commitment to Ireland seems to be wavering some, after the JefFIREland protests and all. So Ireland is trying to rebuild and win at the same time.

That doesn’t work.

I shouldn’t say that so flatly. It works sometimes, but you have to hit on your draft picks. Your rookies have to play very well right out of the gate, and you need to supplement your team with high impact veteran free agents. Sadly, Ireland doesn’t have the best track record in either of those categories. Ireland’s continuous misses on second round picks and constant rejection by prized free agents are evidence of that. For this plan to work, you have to get really lucky. Like the Bengals did last year by hitting on Dalton and A.J. Green in the first round and matching them with a veteran defense for a surprise playoff run. Read that again. OUR BEST HOPE IS BEING THE BENGALS!

I don’t disagree with Ireland’s thought process all the time. He made some smart moves when he was out from under Parcells, and he refuses to commit big money to players who don’t deserve it. He hasn’t killed the cap with a mediocre team, he just can’t bring in the talent to make us better than mediocre. I think he is a smart guy but I think he is just a crappy salesman. So is Stephen Ross. That doesn’t matter much when you are drafting college kids with no options, but it won’t win over Peyton Manning, Jim Harbaugh, or even Ryan Clark.

For the Dolphins that shouldn’t matter. We are not one player away. We are not two players away. Our best isn’t good enough. We don’t need a quarterback for a three year playoff run, we need to build this organization from the ground up. We are just getting the foundation together and people are screaming for us to slap on a coat of paint. We have some young pieces here, but we need a cornerstone, a franchise QB. As much as I would have loved to see number 18 in aqua and orange, we need to find our own guy in the draft. The good news is that the price for first round picks has gone way down. Now it is not such a risky investment. A Jamarcus can’t sink your franchise like he could in the past. So what should we do? Pick a QB in the first round! The last one we picked in the first round was Marino! I don’t think Tannehill is a 1st round pick, but if he is the best QB available, take him. If he doesn’t work, take another QB in the 1st round next year. Stockpile them. Keep picking them until you find one. Because when you find one, you become relevant, and you win. Keep taking QB’s until we find our Matt Stafford, our Cam Newton, or even our Andy Dalton.

I know how quick fans are to call for the GM’s head. But I value consistency so much that I end up defending Ireland. I just don’t want to bring in another blueprint. I tell people to give him a chance to get his own players, lets see the whole puzzle before judging the pieces, trust the vision. Give him a chance to build through the draft. So we miss on the quick fixes, we can still build for the long haul, the right way, with young talent. But its getting harder to do. Normally, I can see a GM’s reason for making a move. I can understand his logic even if I don’t agree with it. Currently, it just looks like Ireland is scrambling. I don’t see his logic in the process and have a hard time discerning the motivation behind his moves.

A real leader will make unpopular decisions if they are the right decisions. He will make those decisions if he has a vision he believes in, and sees the team or organization moving towards the fulfillment of that vision.

But today, I fear that Ireland may be leading us all in the dark.

Friday, February 10, 2012

Meet the New Regime



There’s been a lot of turnover in the Dolphins’ organization this off season. It is always an awkward situation when my favorite team gets a bunch of new people in charge. Especially when these people have no ties to the organization or city and they were just working for a competitor a few months ago. Then the fans, who have been living for this team their whole lives, place what is so dear to them in the hands of these complete strangers who do not have nearly as much invested.

It's like if you were renting a basement apartment your whole life and occasionally the owners would sell the house to new people, but say “Yeah, there’s a guy renting out the basement, he knows all about the house and really loves it, because it’s been his home his whole life.” Then, the new owners, who have no attachment to the house, come in and change out your furniture and tell you how you are supposed to use your rooms because its their house. Now, to get the full sports effect, imagine that your dad had lived in that basement apartment and loved it as well. Maybe his dad did, too.

Well, this analogy is getting creepy, but you get the point. Let’s meet the new strangers living in our house.

Jeff Ireland

Let’s start with a familiar face. Ireland kept his post as GM and basically gained more power over the off season, becoming the football head of the Dolphins and Stephen Ross’ most trusted employee.

I know, everyone loves to bag on Ireland, but he hasn’t done that bad of a job. He just hasn’t found us a quarterback. I think it is only fair to judge Ireland on what he did this past year after Parcells left. Before that, any personnel moves were based on the Tuna’s discretion far more than Ireland’s judgment.

You can’t really judge a draft class for about three years, but the early indications are that the 2011 class was a good crop for Ireland. The first pick, Mike Pouncey, looks like a pillar for the future on the offensive line. Daniel Thomas showed flashes for a few games of becoming an effective back in the NFL. Clyde Gates was an attempt to bring in desperately needed speed. And I think Ireland hit on two of his late picks. Charles Clay is a special athlete at the full back position, and Jimmy Wilson can play corner back. In Wilson’s defense, he probably should have been drafted higher if it wasn’t for that pesky murder charge. What a steal!

Most NFL teams take 6-10 players in a given draft. The rule of thumb is that if you can find three good players, that’s a good draft. Ireland might have grabbed five.

He filled holes in free agency without committing big money to undeserving players. He didn’t give Ryan Clark a big contract at a low impact position. He had the vision to trade for Reggie Bush. Nobody thought that was a good move, but Reggie put up 1,000 yards this season, and made Kim Kardashian regret ever letting him go.

Ireland’s biggest move of the off season probably was NOT trading for Kyle Orton. Half of Miami was clamoring for the Dolphins to give up more than a 1st round pick for Kyle Orton and his wonderful neck beard. Can you imagine if we would have done that? That would have been enough to fire Ireland, for me. We didn’t trade for Orton, he lost his job to Tebow a few weeks later, and found mild interest on the waiver wire. Ireland brought in Matt Moore instead, who played better than anyone thought he would, and was a top 10 quarterback in the NFL for about six weeks this season.

All in all, it was a pretty good off season for Jeff Ireland. I know its easy to make him the punching bag, but let’s give him another year or two before we kick him out, Miami. I’ve already discussed how the Dolphins are trying to piece together multiple blueprints. We need some consistency to find success.

Joe Philbin

Our new, 58 year old, upstairs neighbor. We brought in Ol’ Joe from Green Bay, where he has been the offensive coordinator since 2007. Since then, Green Bay has finished in the top 10 in points and yards. That’s pretty good. While he didn’t call the plays, he did put together the offense during the week. Of course, Joe’s scheme was complemented by a great Brett Favre season and the best quarterback in the league, Aaron Rodgers.

I’m rooting for Joe Philbin. His son just tragically died, and it would be a great story if he won the Superbowl. I just want someone who can stick around for a while. I hope Philbin is the guy.

Philbin is bringing a West Coast offense with him: a passing offense with a high completion rate, and a lot of points. As someone who loves the artistry of the game, as well as winning, this is a welcome addition.

More importantly, Philbin is bringing a connection to many Green Bay free agents. The two most prized are tight end Jermichael Finley and back up quarterback Matt Flynn. Now the word on the street is the Packers are going to franchise tag one of these players, but the Dolphins would be in the running for whichever player they let hit the free agency market.

Aaron Rodgers said Flynn would be a good fit in Miami, and it sounds like Finley LOVES Philbin. The dude gushed over him all Superbowl week. That’s good for us.

My guess is that the Packers slap the franchise tag on Finley and let Flynn go. Flynn already knows Philbin and his system and Miami would be a likely landing spot. I’m weary though. We have been down the promising-back-up-with-a-few-good-games route before. (See A.J. Feeley) But, the good game that Flynn had, wow! He broke nearly every Packers’ single game passing record in the books against a playoff team fighting for a spot. It was impressive. Impressive enough to knock some of the luster off of Aaron Rodgers' stellar season.

Where we went wrong before, betting on a back up quarterback who might have been a product of the system, we have fixed. If we go get Matt Flynn, we don’t have to worry if he is a system quarterback, because we are bringing in the system, too.

Really, I don’t think the head coach matters as much as we think. The players matter. More than that, the quarterback matters. Just look at Jim Caldwell’s glassy stare for proof. That guy went to the Superbowl!

Mike Sherman

Mike Sherman was the head coach at Texas A&M, before that he was the head coach at Green Bay, and originally was Joe Philbin’s boss. Now thanks to the old boys network of coaching, he is our new offensive coordinator.

I mildly like the hire. I’ve liked A&M’s offense the past few seasons, and Sherman has made his quarterbacks look good enough to go pro, but I have been surprised by the team’s lack of overall success.

Hopefully this is the right mix of coaching and responsibility for Sherman. Enough coaching to improve the players, not too much responsibility to cost us late in games with bad time outs and challenges.

Hiring Sherman means the Fins might draft Ryan Tannehill late in the draft. Tannehill was the starting QB for Sherman’s Aggies and would be a late round investment. Some of the Dolphins guys that have looked at him have a surprisingly high opinion of him. He might blossom into something, and since it looks like the Fins will miss out on Luck and RG3, they may have no choice but to take a gamble on a 5th or 6th round QB to develop. He could be a sleeper.

I think that we will keep Matt Moore, bring in Matt Flynn (or maybe Peyton!), and draft Tannehill or another late round QB, and let them all compete in camp. We will spread our money on QBs and hope we strike gold with one of them, and hope none of them do this. If that doesn’t work, maybe next year we will get a 1st round QB.

Kevin Coyle

Who?

Yeah, I had to look him up, too. Let me tell you who Kevin Coyle is. He is a relative unknown in coaching circles. He was most recently the defensive backs coach for the Cincinnati Bengals. Coyle has some coordinating experience in college at places like Maryland, Syracuse, and Holy Cross. That’s about all I know on the guy. I guess its okay. The Bengals had some good corners these past few years.

I am slightly worried that our defense will regress this year, but I think that it is inevitable. I liked Mike Nolan, and think he is a good coach. Our defense has been in the top 10 the past few years he has been around, but he left to take the job in Atlanta.

I think our defense would have regressed with or without Nolan this year. While Nolan is a good coordinator, he benefited from the Dolphins playing a ball control type of offense. This limited possessions for the other team, and kept scores low, making Nolan look great.

With this new passing offense, and hopefully high scoring offense, of Philbin and Sherman, the Fins will let up more points. That’s not a bad thing, that’s just what happens when you score more, and you score quickly. This is the reason the Saints and Patriots always have poorly rated defenses, and the Ravens and Jets have high rated defenses.

The one thing to look at this year is how Cam Wake performs without Mike Nolan. Nolan had a knack for developing pass rushers and played an aggressive defense that I loved. Under Nolan, Wake became a premiere pass rusher in the NFL. Before Miami, Mike Nolan did the same thing with Elvis Dumervil in Denver. I wouldn’t be surprised if Wake’s numbers dipped this year, and somebody in Atlanta posted a lot of sacks.

All in all, it doesn’t look like a bad coaching staff. It’s not like we hired Wannstedt again. (The Bills just promoted him again.)

Only time will tell how this staff fares out. More importantly, we need a quarterback. A franchise quarterback. One we can build around.

While I’m bummed we didn’t get Chip Kelly, I like getting an unknown guy. There is some risk with Philbin, he could be a bust, or he could be the next Bill Walsh. We’ll see.

Thursday, January 12, 2012

Who Should be the Dolphins’ Next Head Coach?



I refuse to feed into the media hype and write about the Heat, after two close, overtime losses. The regular season does not matter to this team. The Heat could win the rest of their games this season but if they don’t win the championship, it would be viewed as a waste.

So instead of discussing LeBron’s phantom travel, our discussion will focus on the next head coach of the Miami Dolphins.

Jeff Fisher

The leading candidate for some reason unknown to me is Jeff Fisher.

I’m not sure what I’m missing. Every sign points to Fisher being a well respected, average coach for 17 years. Average might be kind. In case you haven’t heard, the man only had six winning seasons in 17 years. You might say to me, “Craig, its hard to win in the NFL. Six winning seasons is an accomplishment that shouldn’t be laughed at.” What I might say back to you is, “You are wrong. Dave Wannstedt had four winning seasons in four and a half years as head coach. I can laugh at whatever I want.”

Fisher’s recent track record includes him drafting a quarterback in the first round, that quarterback playing surprisingly well and leading the team to the playoffs, then Fisher quarrelling with him, benching him, shaking his confidence, and then cutting his Pro Bowl quarterback.

That is not a scenario that I would enjoy watching in Miami.

Jeff Fisher is a relatively big coaching name, he has been around a long time, and has a lot of experience, albeit mediocre experience, but experience nonetheless. I understand the interest.

Stephen Ross wants to bring him in with all the flash and show of his helicopter ride across Davie. He wants to convince us that Fisher is going to come in and fix this team.

I’m not buying it.

Its nothing personal Jeff, but I don’t think we should throw big time money at you just because the coaching market is thin this year. Just because you are the only coach people have heard of, does not make you the right choice for the job.

I would rather have a coach with something to prove, an up and comer of sorts, a coach that’s hungry, and a coach that will score points.

I do not want the Dolphins to be Jeff Fisher’s retirement destination.

So let’s look at my candidates. There are only two that really intrigue me.

Rob Chudzinski

I am going with consensus around the league and coaching history. Chud is a hot commodity right now and supposedly on many wish lists for head coaching jobs currently available.

Chud is the offensive coordinator for the Carolina Panthers. The Panthers had a top 10 offense this year while finishing near the bottom of the league last year. Granted, they brought in Cam Newton as well this off season, so Chud can’t take all the credit, but Chud’s impact can’t simply be dismissed.

Before taking over as offensive coordinator at Carolina, he was the tight ends coach at San Diego. I don’t know if you are familiar with San Diego’s tight end. His name is Antonio Gates, and the kid can ball.

Prior to that, he worked as offensive coordinator with the Browns. I know, I know, not another guy with Cleveland stink on him, but Chud was the coach the year the Browns won 10 games, Derek Anderson threw for 29 touchdowns, and then went to the Pro Bowl. This guy made Derek Anderson a Pro Bowl QB! DEREK ANDERSON! I hope that is on his resume, written just like that.

I’ve long been clamoring for more athletic tight ends in Miami, and I’m confident that Chud would bring in some of those guys. I personally think the two tight end, single back offense will be the next fashionable offense to run in the NFL. Belichick is already ahead of the curve on that one. This is the offense Chud would run, and I think it would work down here. It is also my favorite offense to run in Madden 12, so Chud’s got that going for him, too.

On top of the $8 million dollars we are apparently willing to give to Fisher (according to Kim Bokamper, “trusted” league source) Chud has other reasons to take the job. He has ties to Miami that might convince him to coach down here.

Chud played tight end at the University of Miami in the late ‘80s, the glory days. He won two national championships during his stay. He was also the offensive coordinator at UM for three years, one of them being the hallowed 2001 championship season. That was the loaded UM team with Andre Johnson and Willis McGahee and about 20 other future NFL players that ran through the Big East and won it all.

Chud is hungry, has a lot of potential, a Miami pedigree, and an offensive mind. I would love to see him on the sidelines next year.

Chip Kelly

Kelly is currently the head coach at Oregon football, and also currently happy with his job. So that’s an obstacle.

But Chip Kelly is the man I want in charge of the Dolphins.

Internet rumors have been swirling around this past week that the Miami Dolphins contacted Kelly’s agent about their coaching vacancy.

No reputable source has confirmed that this happened except for Kelly’s agent. However, all agents confirm any rumor about interest in their client. It normally leads to more money, so its hard to trust.

With that aside, the rumors had to start somewhere and even if they are completely unfounded, maybe the noise will get loud enough for Stephen Ross to notice and interview the man.

Chip Kelly has been the head coach for three seasons at Oregon. Since his promotion, the team has gone 34-6, won three Pac-12 titles, gone to a national championship, and put up around 40 points and over 400 yards a game.

That’s what I’m talking about! Bring the chrome helmets too!

There is no human on Earth who watches an Oregon football game and doesn’t drool over their high paced, explosive offense. Not only do they win football games but they are aesthetically pleasing as well. I know, that’s not as important, but it is a nice touch.

Recent struggles from big time college coaches like Nick Saban and Steve Spurrier have left people soured on the prospect of NFL teams hiring college coaches but I think Kelly could succeed.

First off, Saban did a pretty good job his first year here, after a rough start we rallied to 9-7. The defense was solid, and the team was gritty. My theory is that he knew he wanted to leave early on in his second season and go back to college, and things fell apart when his heart wasn’t in it, not because he didn’t have the skill.

The other problem that Saban had was that he stuffed the team with old players that were expensive and aged quickly after he left. He just generally didn’t know how to build a professional football team and he had the final say over player transactions.

This won’t be Chip Kelly’s problem. Stephen Ross and the Dolphins have already showed that they are committed to Jeff Ireland. His post as general manager will be much stronger and he will hold much more say over personnel than Randy Mueller (the old GM) did during Saban’s time. So we won’t have to worry about Kelly messing up the roster building, but we do still have to worry about Ireland screwing up in that department.

Also, the recent success of spread players in the NFL bodes well for college coaches who run the spread. The success of Cam Newton, Tim Tebow, and various other Florida, Oregon, Missouri, and Boise St. skill players makes me think that the NFL is already trending toward hybrid spread offenses. If you look at the Eagles over the past 10 years, and the Patriots before they changed their system, they were practically running the spread in the NFL and having a lot of success with it.

I think Chip Kelly’s spread offense could work in the NFL, and I think Chip Kelly could work in the NFL. He is smart, confident, and the number one candidate on my coaching wish list. Hiring him would bring the buzz and attention that Stephen Ross craves, and he would be worth bringing out the chopper for. Above the noise, if Chip Kelly came in and we moved up in the draft to get a spread QB to run his system (like RG3), it would result in me watching the Dolphins win football games on Sunday while scoring a lot of points. To me, that’s heaven.