Showing posts with label Dolphins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dolphins. Show all posts

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Dolphins Rebuilding Plan




Tony Sparano is out as Dolphins’ head coach. Before the NBA gets up and running and consumes South Florida and this blog along with it, I need to carve out some time to discuss the recent developments in Davie.

First of all, I’m sad to see Sparano go on a personal level. I loved his ever present sunglasses, his reliance on statistics, the way he chomped on gum as his jaw bulged with the tension of the job, his enthusiasm for field goals, and having a big Italian guy with a mafioso name running the team. It should have worked. He should have ascended to a nickname like “the Godfather,” retired and opened up a successful chain of gourmet pizza shops in Plantation. But it didn’t happen.

Tony is out. You can’t really blame the owner, the team is flawed but talented and starting 0-7 is inexcusable. There needed to be accountability at the top of the organization and a change in leadership. Keeping Jeff Ireland at GM has been a controversial decision and while I think the local media is swinging too far in his defense, the dude hasn’t proven he is more than an average GM, I am alright with him staying another year. Just because that means we don’t have to bring in another blueprint and go through the fiasco of overhauling the roster again.

This team has some talent, and some obvious weak spots. I decided to hash out the keepers on the team from the junk. This handy list will help you in deciding if you should applaud Ireland’s move this off season or fork his lawn.

Let’s start off with the bonafide studs on the team, the elite players that any team would love to have. By my accounts there are only four. That pretty much sums up why the Dolphins have been struggling.

The Studs:

-Jake Long LT: He was the number 1 pick just a few years ago. He has had a down year because he has been hurt, but he is a young Pro Bowler at left tackle and would be valued as a franchise player on the open market. You keep Jake Long, end of story.

-Vontae Davis CB: For a long time I thought Sean Smith would be the better pro between our two young cornerbacks, but Davis has won me over. He has great athleticism, Brett Favre’s endorsement as one of the best young corners in the league and a disturbingly appropriate nickname for a bothersome corner. NFL receivers just can’t get rid of VD.

-Brandon Marshall WR: No one doubts that Brandon Marshall has the talent and physical tools to be the dominant receiver he was in Denver, he just hasn’t had the quarterback while he has been here. My favorite part of the Matt Moore experience has been his lack of fear in feeding Marshall the ball. Moore throws it up for him even if Revis is covering him, and given the chance, Marshall comes down with the football more often than not. This last half of the season has reminded me of Marshall’s elite talent, you can unquestionably win the Superbowl with Marshall as your number one receiver. As long as he doesn’t get stabbed by his wife again, I think he will break some Miami receiving records when we get a QB to pair up with him.

-Cameron Wake OLB: I debated whether or not he should be included in the “studs” list. He had a breakout year and was a Pro Bowler in 2010 but has slowed down this year. My uninformed hypothesis is that he is drawing double teams and freeing up space for Old Man Jason Taylor to work his way up the all time sack leader board. It comes down to the fact that unless you are the Pittsburgh Steelers its hard to find pass rushers. Wake still has a few years left of top shelf production, thus Derek Cameron Wake is a keeper.

Keepers (not elite, but productive role players you can win with, and possible future franchise guys):

-Reggie Bush HB: Reggie made Miami look really smart this past off season. He shut up his critics by staying healthy, running between the tackles, and he is closing in on a 1,000 yard season. Running backs have a short prime, Bush is still damaged goods (due to his injury history and his romance with Kim Kardashian), and this could be a one year abberation, but the Fins got him for cheap and he’s earned the right to be the feature back going into next year.

-Charles Clay FB: Sure he sometimes struggles in pass protection and run blocking, but he is a fullback that catches bombs! He is averaging 16.5 yards per catch. You have to keep a fullback with that unique skill set.

-Mike Pouncey C: He may be on the studs list in a couple of seasons. He is a promising young center. I know for the Dolphins it is commonplace but most teams don’t have first round picks playing on the offensive line, you have to keep an investment like that. It just so happens this investment looks solid.

-Daniel Thomas HB: A ho-hum young running back that has shown flashes of being special. We got him on the low, no reason to cut the chord yet.

-Jared Odrick, Randy Starks, Paul Solai, Kendall Langford DL: Say what you want about Jeff Ireland, but the dude has got an eye for defensive lineman. We have a wealth of talent on that side of the trenches and the 3-4 defense can be successful without elite D lineman. Keep ‘em if you can get them to stay for cheap.

-Karlos Dansby MLB: The self proclaimed best linebacker in the NFL has clearly lost a step this season but he has still played at a high level. We have too much money in him to move him, we might as well enjoy this level of play while it lasts.

-Sean Smith CB: He is a keeper, Miami fans! I know he drops picks and blows assignments from time to time but he is a rare blend of size and speed at cornerback. We need to hold on to him and cross our fingers that he isn’t the next Jason Allen.

-Jimmy Wilson CB: Yeah, I know he allegedly killed a guy but that hasn’t stopped Ray Lewis. He is a rookie with a nose for the ball and just a playmaker. He already had some timely picks and a punt block this season. If he didn’t have that whole murder trial thing, he probably would have been drafted much higher. Jimmy Wilson is a keeper.

Fringe (players on the bubble of the keeper list):

-Davone Bess WR: Bess is a tease. Some weeks he looks like Wes Welker with braids, some weeks he looks like an average possession receiver. Well at least we haven’t given him a big extension before we figured it out. Wait, what? We already did?

-Koa Misi OLB: Also known as Koa “Missing” because he is never around the ball. On a defense where everybody seems to have their moments in the sun, Misi is stuck in the shadows. But he is still very young and quietly racks up tackles. He may turn into something, but I won’t be heartbroken if we go in another direction.

-Yeremiah Bell SS: For a long time he was the heart and soul of this team at safety. He may have one or two more effective years left, but I don’t know if it will be worth his asking price. We shall see.

-Dan Carpenter, Brandon Fields K/P: The way the NFL recycles the same 50 kickers regardless of recent perfomance, I honestly have no idea how they evaluate them. I didn’t know where to put our kickers, so I put them here.


Everyone Else:

Can go. Or stay. I don’t care. Their collective presence won’t largely impact the Dolphins’ Superbowl odds. All apologies to JT 99, thanks for everything, but you’re time is almost up.

Next Step:

As you can see, we have some semblance of a foundation. We are still a few pieces away. I would like to see the Dolphins revamp the right side of their O-line, and draft an athletic, pass catching, tight end, but the crux of the issue is at quarterback. If we can draft and develop an elite passer, I am confident that this team can win a Superbowl no matter who coaches them. (Please! Don’t let it be Brian Schottenheimer!) Can you picture it? I can see RG3 or Matt Barkley throwing the Superbowl winning touchdown pass to Brandon Marshall, then Reggie Bush showing off his beautiful biceps during the post game press conference.

I’m already excited for next season. 16-0 baby!

Friday, November 18, 2011

Four Years Later: Why Did the Dolphins Ever Trade Wes Welker?



I miss Wes Welker.

The last time the Dolphins were this bad, Wes Welker was the only bright spot.

Its frustrating to see us with two wins and look across the East Coast to see Wes Welker threaten Jerry Rice's single season receiving record.

That tiny white man can play.

I remember watching Wes Welker play for the Miami Dolphins from 2004-2007 and slowly morph into everyone's favorite player.

The dude did everything. He returned punts, kicks, caught passes, even kicked a few field goals for us.

Everyone was bummed when the Dolphins traded him to the Patriots. He was the only weapon that worked against the Pats. But we all consoled ourselves, told ourselves that Welker was an was a flash in the pan and we won the trade. I remember talking myself into the thinking that the Dolphins could find a bigger, more prototypical wide receiver for the 2nd round pick that New England gave us that would surpass Welker's production.

I was wrong.

When you have a talent like Wes Welker, you hold on to him.

The Patriots gave us their 2nd round pick and 7th round pick that year for Wes.

So, now that we have four years of perspective on the move, what did the Dolphins end up with?

In typical Dolphins fashion, we replaced a dazzling skill player with offensive linemen.

The first cog in that trade was Samson Satele, who was picked with that second rounder. Ol' Cam Cam also picked a guy named Abraham Wright with that 7th round pick, a defensive end I've never heard of, and unless you are Abraham Wright's mom, you've never heard of him either.

This was during Cam Cameron's one year reign of "failing, forward, fast." For some reason, Cam had an obsession with the Pacific islands and loved to draft Samoans and graduates from University of Hawaii.

Samson Satele was a part of that bunch, an undersized center from Hawaii and a two year starter for the Dolphins. He didn't miss a game and proved to be a solid piece of the 2008 "wildcat" team. He was a big part of that offensive line that bullied front sevens and created a potent rushing attack.

But Satele couldn't last under Parcells. Parcells hates exceptions. He has standards for every position and if someone doesn't fit the physical parameters, they are gone. He is known for not drafting exceptions because before you know it, there is a team full of exceptions. Which is a fine system if you find players that fit your expectations and have, you know, talent. But instead he drafts 6'5 wide receivers like Patrick Turner that everyone says has no big play ability and very little potential. You have to love it when your team takes fliers on guys with limited potential.

So Satele was replaced by the bigger Jake Grove, and traded to Oakland for a 6th round pick. Grove signed a big contract but never could match the production of Satele and flamed out after a year with the Dolphins. The offensive line clearly took a step back and the running game suffered as the Dolphins limped to a 7-9 record.

Following the paper trail from Wes Welker, the Dolphins performed the worst magic trick in the world and transformed a 2nd round pick into a 6th round pick.

That 6th round pick became Andrew Gardner, an offensive tackle that has been an occasional spot starter at various points on the line and was soon released. He now plays with the Texans. A far cry from the Pro Bowl receiver we traded away.

That's where the value completely ends.

So lets review that one more time. The Dolphins say, "Hey look at that guy Welker. The fans love him. He does everything well. He provides a spark whenever he touches the ball. The Patriots want him. Stupid Belichick. We can get a better player with that 2nd round pick. A strong player, a center."

Then that center slowly turns into an empty roster spot.

Four years later, the Dolphins have nothing to show for the deal and the Patriots have a future Hall of Fame receiver who might set the record for most receiving yards in a single season.

We essentially gave the Patriots Wes Welker for NOTHING.

But hey, at least we didn't repeatedly try to fix the offensive line with resources from the Welker trade, then fail so badly that we had to take ANOTHER center, in the first round four years later.

Look, I know that you can look at any team's history and find bad trades. I get it, everyone misses occasionally. But to watch the Dolphins make a succession of moves like this, in which every transaction was questioned every step of the way, and the Dolphins consistently receive diminishing value in return, shows why the Dolphins are in the toilet and the Patriots are looking for their fourth Superbowl win this decade.

The reason why the Dolphins magically turn value into trash is because the lack of continuity in the front office. There is so much turnover every year, that new management comes in and ships out established talent to bring in their own guys, even if they don't get full value in return for their moves.

What you end up with is talented players being traded away for cents on the dollar and bits and pieces of several different visions from several different coaches. The Dolphins are made up of patchwork veterans that Saban brought in, terrible players from the Cam Cameron era, hulking overpriced lineman that Parcells drafted, and flashy ragtag players Sparano and Ireland signed in an attempt to save their jobs.

You can't build a winner like that. You can't take the various blueprints of different failed coaches, mash them together and win a Superbowl.

The sad thing is, this will only be more of the same in the coming months.

Sparano will be fired, and a new coach will come in. He will get rid of the few talented guys that Sparano acquired, just to separate himself from the past regime. He will want to put his own mark on the organization and trade away players at a discount to give him the flexibility to bring in players he likes.

Continually developing the players and not reaping the returns on that time investment.

What happens is that the Dolphins keep conceding value until their is nothing left.

They end up with lopsided deals like Wes Welker for nothing.

Thursday, November 3, 2011

My Thoughts on Suck for Luck




Who is Andrew Luck?



Oh, Andrew Luck.

There hasn't been this much hype about an off season move since the Summer of LeBron. Which worked out pretty well for Miami.

If you have somehow miraculously only watched actual pro football games and not been sucked in to the sports business/free agency/draft hype machine that is ESPN, God bless you. But you might not know who Andrew Luck is.

Let me break it down for you. Andrew Luck is supposedly the best quarterback prospect the NFL has seen since Peyton Manning. The guy is legit. He's been a Heisman contender the past few years, he has an absolutely insane completion percentage of over 70% the past two seasons, and he has a fantastic patchy neck beard.

Mel Kiper Jr. has been foaming at the mouth over this kid since he was a Freshman.

Andrew Luck is a stud. Nearly every team in the NFL wants him at quarterback. He can single handily lead a team back to relevance and he could possibly be the cornerstone of an NFL dynasty.



Will He Be Any Good in the NFL?



I dunno.

Everybody says he will. I've been on the Luck bandwagon since watching a Stanford game late in his Freshman season. He has the most important tool that I look for in a quarterback: accuracy.

I mentioned Luck's completion percentage earlier, the dude can put the ball on a dime. The reason that I value accuracy over any other trait in a QB is because it makes a player a less risky pick. Very few accurate QBs turn into less than serviceable players.

If you take a "rocket arm" "gunslinger" in the draft, who's biggest plus is his throwing power, he might develop into the next Brett Favre, or the next Jamarcus Russell.

Give me accuracy any day over arm strength. An accurate quarterback's ceiling is Drew Brees and his floor is Chad Pennington. You can win in the playoffs with either guy.

I think Luck will be a good to great NFL quarterback and I am not alone on this opinion. However, this week was the first time that I saw some analysts on ESPN criticizing Luck. What were they criticizing? Arm strength. I'm no pro scout but the guy looks like he can make all the throws necessary at the NFL level. As Jerry Jones famously quoted, at this point I think they are just "circumcising mosquitoes."

Ultimately its a crap shoot and we don't know how he will turn out, but Luck is as close to a sure thing as we have seen in a decade.



Where Will Luck End Up?

I think there are two distinct groups for Andrew Luck. Ideal fits, and close fits. I ran through the NFL teams and think 14 of the 32 teams would take Andrew Luck over their starting QB but some would have to think about it more than others. Let's get to the real possibilities.



Ideal Fits:





1. Miami Dolphins



Yes, I'm biased and I want Andrew Luck. However, the truth of the matter is that Miami is the most sensible place for Luck to land, and one of the two teams with the best shot to get the first pick. Getting the first pick is huge for the Dolphins, we don't want to end up with a top 5 pick and have to trade up for Luck. That puts our assets up against other teams' assets and there is no guarantee we would have the firepower to make a deal. If we did make a deal we would have to give up multiple 1st round picks and some Pro Bowl talent. The difference between the first pick and the second pick for the Dolphins is Andrew Luck and a first round receiver next year, or Andrew Luck, no 1st round picks for 3 years, and Cameron Wake or Vontae Davis would probably be gone.

But I digress, Miami is a perfect fit because Henne's contract is expiring and he probably doesn't want to come back to Miami due to the 10 years playoff-less frustration we have laid on his shoulders and none of the other quarterbacks on the team will be heavy on the books next year.

We are 0-7 and an easy win doesn't look like its coming down the line. Don't listen to those snobby players in the locker room, real Dolphins fans are cheering for losses. Big picture fans want to fix the franchise and Luck is our best shot.

And for those fans that don't believe in Luck and listen to the critics talk about his arm strength and wonder if he can make the throws, what else do you want us to do? Who else do we draft? Luck might not be everything he is projected to be, but we have to take a shot on a QB sometime. The change in CBA rules means that rookies sign much more feasible contracts. He wouldn't be as big of a risk as Sam Bradford was. We need to dare to be more than mediocre Miami. We need to take a QB in the first round.

Do you know who was the last quarterback we picked in the first round? Dan Marino.

That worked out pretty well for us.


2. Cleveland Browns



Cleveland was a trendy playoff pick before the season but they have struggled out of the gate. Their much talked about new West Coast offense has not worked with Colt McCoy and company.

They may be in a position to get a high pick but more importantly they look like a prime landing spot for Luck. Their starting quarterback of Colt McCoy looks more like a career back up than a starter at this point. (Another guy with a high floor because of good accuracy.) Plus, he doesn't have a big contract because he wasn't a first round pick.

On a side note, I'm sorry Longhorn fans. It looks like Colt is on the verge of being forgotten. He never won a national championship and he will probably lose his starting job soon. At least he can treasure his Heisman trophy. Oh, wait.


3. Washington Redskins



Look Redskins fans, this isn't going to last. Washington looked competitive at the beginning of the year and is still sniffing first place in the NFC East. Don't let them break your hearts.

Ever since turning from Rex Grossman, who has the confidence of a Pro Bowl QB, to John Beck, the Redskins have been floundering in the standings. Take my advice Redskins fans, the Dolphins drafted John Beck. I've been where you are now. I know how this will end.

You will make a late charge for the number 1 pick.



Close Fits:





4. Seattle Seahawks



Their starting quarterbacks are Tavaris Jackson and Charlie Whitehurst. Pete Carroll benches one, sees whats on the field, dies a little inside, and puts in the other quarterback. He is shampooing his quarterback situation! Its just rinse and repeat.

You can only watch so many pick sixes go the opposite direction before you start looking at college QBs.

There is a chance that Pete Carroll drapes himself in the Cardinal and Gold and targets Matt Barkley in the draft. But Carroll's job will probably be on the line and nobody wants to bet their career on a kid that reminds me at all of Matt Leinart.


5. Denver Broncos



Timmy! The forecast hasn't looked good for Tebow since his biggest supporter, Josh McDaniels got fired. Say what you want but I didn't think Elway or Fox were big Tebow fans since they've arrived in Denver. I think the Holy Spirit has to lead Tebow's Broncos to the playoffs for him to keep his starting job next year.

Broncos are a dark horse candidate for Andrew Luck. (See what I did there? Broncos... dark horse... let's move on.)



Wild Card:





Indianapolis Colts



The Colts have been the only team that looks worse than the Dolphins this year. But it all depends on Peyton Manning. If Peyton can recover from neck surgery and return to form next year they could very well be a playoff contender again and their draft pick might be better used on another position.

But if Peyton can't come back, then the Colts are the luckiest franchise of the past two decades. (See? Another pun!) This would be their first losing season since Peyton's rookie year and it is the only draft since Peyton's with a sure fire quarterback prospect. If Peyton doesn't come back and the Colts end up with the first pick they will take Luck and be a contender again for the next 15 years.

It's just not fair.










Word of Warning:





Whoever drafts Andrew Luck, don't set your expectations too high. He probably won't win the Superbowl in his rookie year. He probably won't even be that good. Sure, he's the best prospect since Manning but look at what Peyton Manning did in his rookie year. He threw 28 picks that year. That's a rookie record of failure. That's not good.

Saturday, October 29, 2011

Miami Sports Hierarchy

So you’ve just moved to Miami. You’re basking in the sunshine, Cuban food, and frightening road rage. You’re also a sports fan and want to immediately insert yourself into the local sports culture. Luckily, I’m here for you.

Why did I write this? Because I am a recent Miami transplant in the DFW and wish someone would make me a road map of this sports town. Also, its my blog and I can write whatever I want.




1. Miami Dolphins



Main Reason: Dan Marino

First of all, you need to know that this is a football town. People in Miami love football as much as they love Gloria Estefan (which is a lot, she’s practically the Oprah of Miami), and the most important football team in town is the Miami Dolphins. Dolfans are born, not converted. Nobody watches our Parcells bred three yards and a cloud of dust offense and decides to give their allegiance to this field goal kicking team. No, the Dolphins are really the only sports team in South Florida with tradition. Parents pass on the Dolphins to their children, and those children to their children.

The most recent time the Dolphins ever inspired neutral football enthusiasts to hitch their hopes and dreams to the aqua and orange was the Dan Marino era. Oh, you’ve never heard of Dan Marino? Then you’re not a football fan, you probably shouldn’t be reading this site, and probably shouldn’t bring that fact up around town. Get this straight, Dan Marino IS Miami. Rick Ross even said it himself.

When Dan Marino was in his prime, we were a force to be reckoned with. Not only did we win, but we won beautifully. Marino would throw precise bombs with his half second release. Marino struck fear into the hearts of opposing teams and fans. The points were guaranteed.

No, we never won a Superbowl with Marino and that’s a sore subject around here, but ask any South Floridian who the greatest quarterback of all time was and the answer is simple.

Close Second Reason: 1972

It won’t be long before you hear Chris Berman talk about the 1972 team popping bottles after the last undefeated goes down. The 1972 Dolphins went 16-0 through the regular season and the playoffs, becoming the only NFL team to complete a perfect season. Sure, the Patriots won 18 in a row a couple years ago, but they couldn’t finish. Thank God for David Tyree’s helmet.

You’re new around here, so do yourself a favor and go look up the 72 Dolphins on Wikipedia. Or if you’re just too lazy to do that, if you ever find yourself in a conversation with a Miami native about the team just say, “Shula, Griese, Csonka. Those were the days.” And stare wistfully into the distance. Your counterpart will most likely start to tear up and shake his head in silence.



2. Miami Heat



Main Reason: The Big 3

“What? I thought you said Miami was a football town.” It is. Just shut up a second and let me explain. No matter how much a civic area is committed to the grid iron, LeBron James changes things.

You have to give it to Mickey Arison and Pat Riley, they are changing the sports culture in Miami. The shot in the arm of Dwyane Wade, LeBron James, and Chris Bosh made Miami feel like a basketball town last year. It was the first time in my lifetime I remember people casually talking about Heat regular season games. Even when we had Shaq that wasn’t the case.

Miami loves flash and star power. Bring us possibly the greatest basketball team ever assembled and we will pack the stadium every game. . . halfway through the second quarter.

Close Second Reason: Alonzo Mourning

We love this tall black man with one kidney. And Zo loves Miami. Google Zo’s Summer Groove. If it wasn’t for frickin’ Michael Jordan, the Miami Heat would have banners up in the rafters celebrating the Mourning-Hardaway teams. Why does MJ always have to ruin everything?



3. College Football



Main Reason: Miami, UF, FSU

These three teams won a combined 10 national championships in the past three decades and should have had more. Each program taking its turn atop the college football universe. Its not a surprise. South Floridians think that we have the best football in the world. You look at any D-1 team and will find some South Florida products there. Its something in the water, you can’t find this kind of speed anywhere else. If you don’t believe me, go to a Carol City-Miami Northwestern game and tell me you’re not impressed. (Just remember to lock your doors, these high schools produced “Thug U.”) Needless to say, the top cut of these future pros normally grow up rooting for one of these three schools and are easily swayed by their recruiters to attend.

Close Second Reason: USF, UCF, FIU, FAU

This is the second tier of Florida football. But these programs are up and coming and feisty. They also deal with a severe inferiority complex of not being in the big three in the state. Thus every year one of them will start 5-0 and declare that they have moved into the big three in place of _____ (whichever of the top schools lost a game) but they normally fade away late in the year and dominate some crappy bowl game.



6. Florida Marlins



Main Reason: Two World Series wins

Soon to be the Miami Marlins. As you can see, there is a precipitous drop from college football to baseball in this town. Don’t believe me? Look at the stands in Sun Life Stadium. One reporter claimed to have counted every fan in the stadium for a game this year. The number reported: Over 10,000. The number of fans he counted: 300.

Sure, we’ve won two championships in the past 15 years but we’ve only made the playoffs twice in that same span. Most Marlins seasons consist of us slashing payroll and trading away any players the fans get attached to. Every once in a while we hit the jackpot on prospects and they gel together into a championship team, but those instances are rare. Of course Cubs fans would probably kill for the odds we’ve had.

There is hope. The long held myth of the Marlins has been that since they’ve had to play in the Dolphins’ stadium and couldn’t reap any of the revenue from stadium purchases the team has had to keep the payroll low. Somehow the Marlins convinced the city of Miami to build them a new 37,000 seat stadium on the old Orange Bowl site to house their 300 fans. But they’ve promised to increase payroll and Cubans will always love baseball.

The best part of a Marlins championship? Pots and pans parades down Calle Ocho.

Close Second Reason: Aliases



10. Florida Panthers



Main Reason: Year of the Rat

If you ask somebody around town about the Panthers, you will probably get a response like, “Wait, they play hockey outside of Canada?” And for good reason. We went to the Stanley cup one year in the ‘90s and lost. I was too young and the memory is foggy. All I remember is people throwing rats onto the ice and John Vanbiesbrouck. That’s about it for proud Panthers moments.

However, there is also hope with the Panthers. After 10 years of mediocrity, missing the playoffs, and generally killing the fan base, the Panthers finally bottomed out and are rebuilding this year. They’ve put together a young and somewhat talented team in Sunrise and might actually make the playoffs. We see red.

Close Second: Randy Moller